"It's hard to argue with Wimbush's choice to switch commitments, in my opinion. He falls right into the mold of quarterback Brian Kelly has been recruiting since scoring a pledge from Everett Golson almost four years ago now. Kelly wants pass-first quarterbacks with the mobility to, most importantly, extend plays and then run if needed. He's also showing a willingness to run Golson outright. Malik Zaire and DeShone Kizer fall into the same category. Wimbush's combination of arm strength and athleticism gives him a chance to really flourish in South Bend."

"Barnett was a big addition to Alabama's recruiting class as the Crimson Tide wanted to add an elite quarterback. First-year offensive coordinator Lane Kiffin has used a variety of formations this fall, which includes the spread, hurry-up offense and no-huddle. Alabama quarterback Blake Sims has been a dangerous weapon in the Tide's offense with his arm and legs. Barnett's running ability makes him a dangerous weapon in any offense. He will also have plenty of playmakers surrounding him, including the nation's No. 1 wide receiver Calvin Ridley."

"It's odd that Wimbush is a better fit for the Alabama offense and Barnett is a better fit for the Notre Dame offense. Barnett is a better runner. But I think they'll both be very successful under coaches who will use them and utilize their skills. It's a win-win for both programs. Saban has had good success with quarterbacks and they have a quarterback who can run now. Kelly has been very successful with Everett Golson, who is a shorter quarterback."